Okay, I'll bite. How did Ari and Shima meet?
They were introduced.
By whom?
Me.
Fascinating. Please explain.
I met Shima in 2006, my first year coaching the UC Irvine mock trial team. Shima was a sophomore. She played a wonderful witness -- everything from a crying babysitter to a tough police officer to a hair dresser with attitude. She was also a great attorney:
![]() |
Shima performing as a fake lawyer at the 2009 National Championship |
Where does Ari come in?
In late 2007, Shima was getting ready to leave for a study-abroad trip to Europe. Ari planned to be in Europe over the same period. It occurred to me that they were a match -- both good-looking, fun-loving, intelligent youngsters. Though they had never met, I was confident enough in their eventual romance that I made them an offer: I would pay for the second date.
So they met in Europe?
No. Despite my matchmaking effort, they never met up across the Atlantic.
Did you give up?
Obviously not. While Ari and Shima still hadn't met, I may have told people that they were, in fact, already dating. It's even possible that I told people they were engaged. If I did those things -- and I'm not saying I did -- I had the best intentions.
Tell the jury: what happened then?
They both moved to New York City for graduate school and, voila!, now they're happily dating. I don't want to take all the credit for their relationship.
I'd say you deserve about 95 percent of the credit.
I was thinking the same.
Let's turn to the Chicago trip. You said Shima forgot something?
Her driver's license. She arrived Wednesday morning and explained that she left her driver's license in New York.
If she was able to make her flight without an ID, why was that such a big deal?
Shima enjoys adult beverages. A lot. This photo was taken before 9 o'clock in the morning:
Is she clutching a bottle of bourbon like a mother holds a child?
Yes, she is:
I see. So what happened?
Because Shima couldn't easily order drinks in bars and restaurants, and because Ari and Shima wanted to drink before the White Sox-Yankees game, they began the festivities on their own.
Ari pouring Miller Lite into Shima's slurpee cup at the 7-11 |
Ari refilling Shima's slurpee cup aboard the subway |
That's pretty bold. How did you feel about this behavior?
I strongly disapproved. Laws are laws. I love them both, but I just can't condone Ari and Shima's conduct.
Got it. So who took the photos above?
Um. No comment.
All right, Ari and Shima got refreshments at the 7-11 and doubled up on the metro. What happened next?
We got to US Cellular Park, home of the Chicago White Sox. As we approached the stadium, Ari stopped to pour his last Miller Lite into his slurpee cup. A police officer saw him and intervened.
Ari handled things well. He apologized. He showed deference to the officer. I thought everything would be fine.
But?
The officer saw that Shima had a similar cup. He asked her, "What's in your cup?" She was honest. "It's beer." The officer turned to Ari and told him to throw his remaining beer in the trash. But before Ari threw out his beer, Shima did the unthinkable...
She took another swallow of beer.
While standing in front of the police officer?
Yes.
After she told him it was beer?
Right.
After the officer told Ari to throw his beer in the trash?
Yes.
Maybe the officer didn't see.
Oh, he saw. "Did you just take another sip? After I told him to throw his out? You've disrespected me." The officer fumed. Shima admitted that she had. Then things went from uncomfortable to I-hope-Shima-doesn't-get-arrested.
"Ma'am, let me see your ID."
Uh oh.
Shima started fumbling through her purse. After about 15 seconds of rummaging through credit cards and cash, spilling all of it, recognition spread across her face. Her driver's license was still in Manhattan. Recognition turned to panic. "My ID is in New York," she insisted. The officer wanted to know how she got to Chicago without her driver's license. Shima said security allowed it.
The officer wasn't buying it. "I'm a trained police officer. TSA would not allow someone to get on a plane without a driver's license. If you don't want to spend a night in jail, you better show me an ID." Shima kept telling her story and the officer kept reminding us that he was trained.
The man in the center of this photograph is a trained police officer. |
So what happened?
I'll be honest. When he detained Ari, it was funny. I knew nothing bad would happen. When he questioned Shima, it was still pretty funny. But when she kept drinking right in front of him and he saw her -- when he felt disrespected -- I started to worry. Fortunately, Shima is very likable. She smiled her way out of it. The officer told her to throw out the cup. "Take another sip and you will be sleeping in jail tonight," he promised. She obeyed.
I have to ask. Why did she take keep drinking right in front of the officer?
We had the same question. "What were you thinking?" I asked. "How could you take another sip?" Ari asked. Her answer was vintage Shima: "I had a beer in my hand. It was instinct."
She's a keeper.